As of Wednesday morning, Israel’s embassies and consulates across the globe are on strike, including the one in San Francisco that serves Northern California and the Pacific Northwest.
“No consular services will be provided and no one will be allowed to enter,” one ambassador posted on Twitter. Those services include passport renewal and assistance to Israelis living abroad.
Why has Israel’s entire foreign service shut down? In a word: taxes.
Israeli diplomats get lump-sum expense stipends meant to cover a range of personal and official expenses. The Finance Ministry now says it wants the diplomats to submit individual receipts for those expenses and pay sales tax on the personal ones. The taxes would be applied retroactively, which would force the diplomats to pay back from previous years. Sales tax in Israel, which is known as a valued-added tax, or VAT, is currently 17 percent.
The Foreign Ministry is none too pleased.
“Israel’s representatives abroad strive to promote the country’s international standing and strength daily,” a ministry statement published Wednesday said. “The Ministry of Finance is impairing essential tools of the State of Israel and has unfortunately left us with no option other than the closing of all diplomatic missions.”
Here’s a shocker: The Finance Ministry sees thing differently. In a statement to JTA, the ministry said the diplomats are shutting down Israel’s international relations so they can maintain their comfortable lifestyles.
“Foreign Ministry employees are required to pay taxes like every other citizen of the state of Israel,” the ministry said. “It’s a shame that, in an attempt to improve their circumstances, Foreign Ministry employees are refusing to pay taxes and are hindering essential services. Foreign Ministry employees are not above the law.”
This is the latest in a string of grievances from Israeli diplomats, who have long complained of low pay and poor working conditions. Earlier this year, diplomats protested budget cuts to the ministry and, in September, briefly went on strike over another financial dispute. Earlier in September, Foreign Ministry spending was frozen briefly before an emergency cash infusion from the Finance Ministry.
In May, a State Comptroller report found that some Israeli diplomats live in dilapidated conditions.
This week, individual Israeli diplomats from Boston to Ukraine to Ghana posted nearly identical statements on their Twitter feeds.
San Francisco-based Consul General Shlomi Kofman retweeted a message from Emmanuel Nahshon, Israel’s ambassador to Belgium and Luxembourg that read: “Israeli diplomacy is an essential aspect of our national security. We are dedicated civil servants and proud of our work. We are on strike because we are denied the basic financial instruments in order to do our job properly.”
Israeli diplomacy is an essential aspect of our national security. We are dedicated civil servants and proud of our work. We are on strike because we are denied the basic financial instruments in order to do our job properly.Hoping reason will prevail 🇮🇱 https://t.co/JD22HaqFfm
— Emmanuel Nahshon (@EmmanuelNahshon) October 30, 2019