Thursday, January 23, 2014 | return to: views, opinions


Rabbinate’s rejection of Jewish majority is outrageous double standard

by rabbi julie schonfeld

Follow j. on   and 

The good news is in: Rabbi Avi Weiss’ conversions will be accepted in Israel.

9_V_schonfeld_avatar_withnameI am glad to see that his religious integrity and leadership have been acknowledged. Undoubtedly, this course correction on the part of the Israeli Chief Rabbinate is due in part to the hue and cry of influential Jewish leaders, many of whom are not Orthodox, who are to be praised for speaking out.

Of course, my conversions are not recognized in Israel. Nor are those of my 1,700 Conservative colleagues, my 2,000 Reform colleagues and my 300 Reconstructionist colleagues. The fact that Jewish leaders and major organizations are stepping up to address the issue of pluralism is a wonderful step forward and one that we should all applaud and encourage.

But why does this only happen when an Orthodox rabbi’s character is at stake? Where is the statement on behalf of the nearly 4,000 rabbis and the 85 percent of diaspora Jewry we represent when the derogation of our Judaism is black letter law in Israel?

Weiss himself wrote in October in the Times of Israel that “Israel as a state should give equal opportunities to the Conservative and Reform movements. Their rabbis should be able to conduct weddings and conversions.”

Leaders of Jewish organizations and public figures have criticized Israel in defense of Weiss, something far too few have been willing to do for the Conservative and Reform movements. This double standard was expressed stunningly by Rep. Eliot Engel (D-N.Y.).

“If Rabbi Weiss’ credentials are rejected — an Orthodox leader with decades of experience — what does that portend for other strands of American Judaism?” asked Engel, who represents Weiss’ district in the House of Representatives. What indeed?

To those who issued statements in Weiss’ defense that were both bold and effective, I thank you. Now I call upon you to issue a statement for Conservative, Reform and Recon-structionist rabbis. Notify your board members and donors that the rabbis who married them, bar mitzvahed their children, buried their parents and converted their sons- and daughters-in-law do not deserve to be called rabbis in the eyes of the Israeli rabbinate. Tell them that none of their lifecycle events count and that the State of Israel does not really think they are Jews for religious purposes.

The American Jewish establishment will not stand for the discrediting of an Orthodox rabbi. Better than nothing, I suppose, but far less than the Jewish public deserves. Where is the outrage for us? Has the Chief Rabbinate exported its hatred of the streams? Has the Israeli political leadership exported its willingness to ignore the mistreatment of the vast majority of the world’s Jews by an extremist minority?

If we take a long, hard look at ourselves, the best explanation probably comes from a paraphrase of the famous Pogo cartoon “We have met the enemies and they are (also) us.”

Structural intolerance and discrimination do not only harm the abused, but obscure the human dignity of every individual. Such intolerance, allowed not only to survive but thrive, engenders an atmosphere in which it is impossible to treat even your friends and colleagues as your equals. In the words of Maimonides, “A rabbinic prohibition is always and everywhere superseded for the sake of human dignity.”

No one is asking any rabbi or Jew to hold personally by the interpretations of a community or a rabbi with whom they do not agree. But all must be equally respected and acknowledged.

American Jewish leaders derive legitimate authority only on the basis of their integrity and willingness to seek and grasp the convictions of the people they represent. In my experience, the colleagues I serve with are dedicated beyond measure to these ideals. That is what has made this chapter so chilling. We are becoming invisible to ourselves.

As it is written in Ethics of the Fathers, “Other people’s dignity should be as precious to you as your own.”


Rabbi Julie Schonfeld is executive vice president of the Rabbinical Assembly, the international association of Conservative and Masorti rabbis.


Posted by RavGolda18
01/25/2014  at  08:10 PM
When they came for them...

The irony is that while you stand up for the Modern Orthodox, you totally discount those who have graduated from independent seminaries like JSLI, Mesiftah and others.  And, the Conservative Jews used to think Reform Jews were not legitimate too! 

It’s amazing how the movement rabbis now stand with those who previously shunned you, but still stand against those who have had a different journey than yours. Unfortunately, it’s a familiar story!

Login to reply to this comment or post your own

Leave a Comment

In order to post a comment, you must first log in.
Are you looking for user registration? Or have you forgotten your password?

Auto-login on future visits