Thursday, April 11, 2013 | return to: news & features, national


Israel divestment resolutions overturned at U.C. Riverside, defeated at U.C. Santa Barbara

by sean savage,

Follow j. on   and 

The U.C. Riverside student government has overturned a recent student senate resolution that urged the U.C. system to implement Israel divestment.

When the resolution — titled “Divestment of Companies that Profit from Apartheid” — passed in early March, opponents argued that they were not given time to prepare for the vote.

“There was not enough time or opportunity among senators to discuss the resolution … and there was not a presentation of the issue from both perspectives,” student senator Megan Crail, who voted against the resolution March 6, told the campus Highlander News.

This prompted the student government to revisit the resolution on April 3. At a campus auditorium filled to capacity, speakers from both sides presented arguments for and against the resolution, according to student Jackie Zelener, co-president of the university’s Highlanders for Israel, Hillel president, and Emerson Fellow for the pro-Israel education group StandWithUs.

Following the presentations, the student government voted 10-2 to rescind the resolution.

“I am proud of our community for working together through all of this. Hopefully this will be a steppingstone for peaceful dialogue in the future,” said Zelener.

Meanwhile, in a meeting at U.C. Santa Barbara that begin the night of April 10 and didn't until 8 a.m the next morning, according to one report, students senators voted to reject a similar divest-from-Israel resolution. Needing two-thirds majority to pass, the final tally was 11 votes against divestment, 10 in favor and one abstention, according to several sources.

The pro-Israel education group StandWithUs issued a statement April 11, saying: "StandWithUs congratulates the pro-Israel students at U.C. Santa Barbara for their victory this morning over the BDS movement. UCSB student leaders worked tirelessly to defeat a divestment resolution that unfairly singled out and condemned Israel. Their courage and determination paid off ... StandWithUs is proud of student leaders who showed that by challenging lies with the facts and passionately stating the case for Israel, you can overcome a smear campaign."

The divestment resolutions at U.C. Riverside and U.C. Santa Barbara were part of an ongoing global effort by anti-Israel activists on college campuses that has hit California state schools particularly hard.

In late 2012, U.C. Irvine passed a similar divestment resolution. More recently, the student council at U.C. San Diego and the student union at Canada’s York University passed divestment resolutions.

Meanwhile, student bodies at U.C. Berkeley, Stanford University and Oxford University have rejected similar resolutions.

J. staff contributed to this report.


Posted by Theresa
04/11/2013  at  01:34 PM
Another Divestment Failure

The University of Califonia at Santa barbara also defeated a Divestment resolution this week- after 13 hours of debate.  At least the anti-Israel activists can’t claim that their voices weren’t heard. Their voices were heard, and their arguements were rejected.

Login to reply to this comment or post your own
Posted by GaelicNeilson
04/12/2013  at  05:24 AM
Clearly majority of Jewish students

Clearly majority of Jewish students don’t see apartheid Israel as representing them.  StandWithUs is an extremist organization that promotes Zionism and most Jewish students would not want to be a part of such a group.  Take a look at how the group portrays the anti-apartheid movement:
“On Thursday, September 8, StandWithUs released the second issue of its comic book series, “Captain Israel.” In this 12-page issue, the “superhero of our time” takes on the anti-Israel Boycott, Divestment, and Sanctions movement (BDS), depicted as an evil, venomous snake.” (off their website at  )

Login to reply to this comment or post your own

Leave a Comment

In order to post a comment, you must first log in.
Are you looking for user registration? Or have you forgotten your password?

Auto-login on future visits