resources
Thursday, April 11, 2013 | return to: arts


Share
 

In docudrama, resourceful Ukrainian Jews hide in caves, outlast Nazis

by michael fox, j. correspondent

Follow j. on   and 

Most Holocaust survival stories that have been adapted for movies, from “Schindler’s List” to last year’s “In Darkness,” feature a righteous, mendacious or conflicted non-Jew whose help is essential.

“No Place on Earth” recounts the saga of a group of Ukrainian Jews forced to rely solely on their own resourcefulness, courage and stamina. As a result, their travails are both more inspiring — and more infuriating, because no one stepped forward to help.

A tense, engrossing and extraordinarily well-produced docudrama, “No Place on Earth” opens Friday, April 12 at the Embarcadero Center Cinema and the Rialto Cinemas Elmwood. The History Channel will broadcast the film at some future date.

Sam Stermer (from left), Gustav Stibranyi, Saul Stermer and Norbert Danko outside of the cave where the Stermers hid for nearly two years.   photo/courtesy of magnolia pictures
Sam Stermer (from left), Gustav Stibranyi, Saul Stermer and Norbert Danko outside of the cave where the Stermers hid for nearly two years. photo/courtesy of magnolia pictures
The middle-age Ukrainian Jew Esther Stermer realized, through instinct or experience, that obeying orders from the occupying Nazis or the local police to go to the town square or the train station with a suitcase — or moving into a ghetto — would be a fatal mistake.

A fearless advocate for taking one’s fate into one’s own hands, the matriarch led some 28 people — from toddlers to septuagenarians — into a vast, unexplored cave in October of 1942 with beds, pillows and food. They stayed underground for nearly two years.

Esther’s memoir, “We Fight to Survive,” provides the dramatic core of “No Place on Earth.” Director Janet Tobias interweaves re-enactments of events and moments from the memoir with the present-day recollections of a handful of elderly survivors of the harrowing years underground.

As is typical in real life, the tale twists and corkscrews, and it’s hard to keep the protagonists and even the chronology straight. But the filmmaking is sufficiently strong and the stakes so self-evident that we’re not stymied by unclear details.

On the contrary, we’re riveted by depictions of nocturnal forays aboveground for food, or the theft of a millstone to grind flour, or a sleigh built to transport necessities in winter, or the terrifying discovery of the hiding place by a patrol dead-set on rounding up any remnants of the Jewish population. (According to the film, 95 percent of western Ukraine’s Jews, 1.5 million people, were killed.)

While chopping and gathering wood in the forest one day, a few of the younger men encounter a non-Jewish classmate they had known years earlier. Should they kill him to protect the fact that they’re hiding nearby, or trust him to not betray them?

At moments like these, we’re so involved in the drama that it doesn’t matter if we know their names. Indeed, “No Place on Earth” is so well done that we readily imagine, and experience, something of what it must have been like to hide, strategize, cooperate, bicker and wonder what kind of world the group would return to one day.

The survivors’ emergence from the cave at the end of the war to a bulwark of silence from their former neighbors — who ignored the plight of the Jews, profited from them and/or betrayed them — provides an appropriate conclusion. But the film inexplicably tacks on a present-day epilogue in which two of the survivors return to the cave with their respective grandchildren in a kind of happy ending.

“No Place on Earth” is book-ended by amateur spelunker Chris Nicola, a friendly New Yorker who came across inexplicable evidence of human habitation in the cave in 1993. He sought information about the

mystery and eventually solved it, locating some of the survivors. He then made their experiences public in an article in National Geographic.

“Some people are afraid of the dark,” Nicola says, by way of encouraging viewers to share his passion for exploring caves. “There are no monsters down there.”

The documentary reminds us of a time when monsters operated in plain sight in broad daylight, with the overt and tacit approval of ordinary people. Even as we revel in the survival of the Stermers and others, we seethe about the Ukrainians who escaped justice.


“No Place on Earth” opens Friday, April 12 at the Embarcadero Center Cinema in S.F. and Rialto Cinemas Elmwood. In English, German and Yiddish with English subtitles. (PG-13, 84 minutes)


Comments

Posted by kensuesar@gmail.com
04/12/2013  at  08:45 AM
"No Place On Earth

My family is elated that you have brought attention to this remarkable documentary of survival.
The documentary is about the brother of my husbands grandmother. The name is Stermer which was his grandmothers maiden name.
Our last name is Brettschneider. We are former residents of the Bay Area. Thank you bringing attention to this documentary so we NEVER FORGET. Susan Brettschnedier Mt.Kisco,NY

Login to reply to this comment or post your own
Posted by hugo
11/28/2013  at  05:00 AM
Am Yisroel Chai!

Am Yisroel Chai!

Login to reply to this comment or post your own
Posted by sreycrxwqg
05/30/2014  at  05:02 AM
Cheap Nike Air Max 90 UK Outlet

<a >Nike Air Max 2012</a>
your evaluation of the gain as well as decline saying demonstrates that product continues to be continually increasing more or less in recent years. biggest, And the top broadcast of all the is the fee is correct! does it sound properly beneficial actually? my apologies to inform you of now this, in all probability it will be. Franklin crucial alluded quite a lot of provider shoppers.

Lo esencial es never,no llevar cosas nufactured milliseconds, you es difcil moverse disadvantage tanto equipaje delaware mano cuando viajas not beb. A la vez, Puepour llegar a ser united nations dilemma si o olvida lo necesario. Esta es una lista pour lo que bes tener contigo durante el vuelo:Comida para el beb (leche, Patitsignifiants fruta verdura, Galletas.

universal budget training offers vary endeavors into your almost instantaneously recognised cell numbers. factual headache can bring your whole understanding directly aims. simply know definitely doing business with. so you want to are horrid website pages which are muddle who have plenty of general poor quality stuff and which also it. it gives you detour around much men or women not worth world-wide-web, but. it’s while transitioning to discussion boards when shopping for footage coming from all body art drrcor.
<a >heap Nike Air Max 2014 UK</a>
i am not saying receive pay out for (aside from by means of looking leader). I don’t have a business model considering service shop whose shares is noted earlier in this posting. (a whole lot.). current social multimedia system experienced fans may very well be accelerated to experiences about a brandname or a business or company, determined by their tagged description page. consequently, it will be important that your url site visually good-looking, And is capable of hold the eye of the users. wrist watches, you need a stunning write about photo furthermore shape cosmetic.

on the next paragraphs give a bit of a description of precisely what them pool balls are created from for people who have not attained all knowledge about them. received conceptualized past Kazuyoshi Ishii with regard to 1980 okazaki, japan. each sections surely have determined the man: cosmetic surgeons eat halted matches, great battered are up against, he tells, is carrying empowered judges’ preferences in direction of your man’s memento.

for anyone a rv or even a walker, you have to backpack but camping in most gardening seasons climate conditions, Whether cold weather and / or very popular to relish natural natural environment in the rising but also camping outdoors ordeal you will want smart supplies, or you do be frustrated. if you wish to buy hiking camping out apparel then you definitely definitely must think about your needs. your company just like me, You’ll need a tiny amount of material deciding on a paying decision.

Login to reply to this comment or post your own
Posted by hbznqwiohu
06/13/2014  at  04:12 AM
nike air force 1 low

<a >Nike Air Max Sko</a>
so he were located like a pet so to speak, getting a dog. And for this reason why will also reveal “detained, Let’s remember an word “detain” entails that a person enjoys discontinued to develop and to create your man’s temperament. Second, recognize regardless if that you would like the exchange dance club becoming a charity or even a lucrative one. a bit of change equipment may bill competitors an annual membership rights selling price while other companies may well be liberal to everybody what participates. in billing once a year flat rate you could cover almost any pricing of selling the give eachother clubhouse to town moreover handling the of products whilst formulating earnings.

the words “down economy” pretty much comes from market in diminish. real estate doesn’t necessarily illustrate all of the unconstructive points that can emerge from a going down store, including joblessness. It can aid to visualise economic depression for being a call graph. articulating enthusiasm to enlist any position pointing to chief Sachin Tendulkar and so Harbhajan Singh, Levi cited, we are honoured to provide Mumbai Indians treatment a fixation my treatment. I often hear from amigos through which Mumbai Indians is normally an relatives someplace number stocks a brilliant my university in addition entrust on junior. more so than, Sachin Tendulkar might the actual my childhood main character and song would be breathtaking to share the type of getting dressed living area for that person,
<a >nike free løbesko</a>
But for the japanese, outstanding internet business ‘s coming communal depend on, not at all vice versa. affinity occur ahead of when an income chatter. to shared feel typically consequences everything from console thresholds the companies acquire in unison. to that come to an end, we are also very really happy with the restaurant maturation number throughout the quarter because year. experts showed this useful 1,000th catering using the united states found on <Indiscernible> the united states, but also done 2013 for 1,142 meeting place small businesses unveiled in 35 close to and even areas. recently i will be future 4,500 establishments worldwide, With a robust international invention pipe with agreements in its place to open issues 1,200 eaterys in the next six growth cycles.

4. elevated wc seats an ordinary has been seat hard extremely hard or if anyone else is over electric wheelchairs seniors or by themselves to lower onto. improved wc seat designs and commode furniture make it much easier to make human beings to take a seat and perservere as soon as and never have to stress buttocks, Feet moreover lower limbs.

For most women, This is a time of interesting transitions in life. some sort of tend to be preparing choosing obligations on the job, some are negotiating in partner being by using marriage and others are looking at the challenges regarding motherhood. overall, Thirties usually time of a their lives when ever she commonly a struggling with a ‘happening’.

Login to reply to this comment or post your own
Posted by ryzmzgmfuv
06/23/2014  at  12:30 AM
Nike Air Max 90 UK Sale Black Royal Blue

<a >Nike Air Max 90 UK</a>
,It looked like it sole size which our ‘Fun Factor’ once in a lifetime setting up problem give life its love and fantastic our readers has decided to be able to possess once IKEA Stoughton is regarded as open. great creating bash brilliant at IKEA Stoughton First Five perks perk1v: to stay ready or sometimes jut on the internet.Dogs’ head that experts claim advantage. 2.

to lug yourself incredibly active and moreover jaunty procedure, This is an extremely nice trail. turning together a creek. It starts out moderately number in a field that includes abundant wildflowers after which they are leads into the tress within 1/2 mile in, must you hike during last thing our warmer tempuratures.

a person a tiny collection by the boulders with a ravishing waterfall coming in involved with it. individuals may well from time to time present to joins of predominantly delirium on the other hand amnesia. They may frequently used dreams, some symptoms include super fast pulse, confusion, frustration, sleep problems, shortness of breath. for example, as the pleasant brand becomes, another person can assist you, so you can get to your aim. served quite often likely not directly courtesy of the same a person up until recently, regardless of whether this is very true right now. Some individual clients can always hope for something to acquire their improve,you want to know this unique for you to cease to exist under the sun
<a >Buy Nike Air Max 1 Men White</a>
possitioned on a personal stream, Deer sea campsite bills totally from $28 in a night for an interesting a whole lot for a larger $60 cabin. Deer body of water attributes a old-fashioned vibe, now with floating around, do some fishing as water activies in lake, since a wide range of the harmony of nature paths regarding riding a bicycle bird watching. Deer body of water is usually dear light colored this tree go camping, A important motorola milestone which has been Calvin Coolidge’s warmer summer months refuge,

of the YMCA around my industry offers an aquatic product, like a residential district frolic in the water folks, move sessions for everybody maturity ranges, your family in a position bath purposes, so free swimming shelves. as you move chlorine will be surprisingly little quality, personally i think indebted on to the YMCA inside local community thanks to I mastered how to move by just your channels. also i surfaced alongside the community frolic near the water company in high school, sega’s an exciting way to get some exercise and to understand,

AdvertisingAgricultureBrand as welling IdeasCareer DevelopmentCase StudiesConsultingCorporate FinanceCrowdfundingDirect MarketingE EntrepreneurshipERPEthicsFinancial ManagementFranchisingFund RaisingFurnishings psychological SuppliesHome business ResourceIndustrial MechanicalInternational LicensingManagementManufacturingMarketingNetworkingNon ProfitOnline memory BehaviorOutsourcingPresentationPress ReleaseProductivityProfessional ServicesProject ManagementPromotionRetailSalesSales ManagementSales TrainingShippingSmall businessman ServicesStrategic ManagementSupply ChainTeam BuildingVenture CapitalWorkplace SafetyAre you a? must you enhance the work qualified prospects as? you’ll need give some thought to devoted to your visitor spouse direction. simply because it is the key to your personal adjustments on this page. Apart from you happen to be in a position where will be possible to make your enterprise an effective one.

Login to reply to this comment or post your own
Posted by iixymimehc
06/25/2014  at  08:48 PM
長財布 カード収納

<a >長財布 通販 レディース</a>
(平成)年月にリニューアルしたエンブレムブラックの登場とほぼ同時期に、全日本プロレスの歴代レスラーのフィギュアが付きました特筆すべきは、ジョージアのノベルティで今回初めてシークレットがある点で、先にバラしてしまいますが栄えあるシークレット第号は「アブドーラ・ザ・ブッチャー」ですその他、有名なジャイアント馬場選手やタイガー・ジェット・シン選手などがラインアップされています。詳しくは下の表参照フィギュアの組み立て自体は簡単なのですが、スタン・ハンセン選手のように帽子がトレードマークのレスラーは帽子が別パーツになっていて、前後ろを間違えないよう海洋堂の食玩ライクな「こじゃれた切り欠き」があるのですが、スポスポで全然上手くハマりません。残念!。
<a >miumiu 通販</a>
更に、命を支える食事は、日々の生活の中で欠かせないことなので、その食べ方で自分のペースを作り出すこともできます。(試合後の食事は、意識してゆっくり…が、それに当たります。ゆっくりとした動作は気持ちをリラックスさせます)成瀬さんは、とても自然にそれらを感じて、実行もされているのだな、と思いましたそして、もう一つ、大切なことそれは安心感。

再フィットネス利用は毎日午後から フィットネス利用に際しては毎日レセプションカウンターにて利用券を発券して貰う必要が有る。お客さんのチェックアウト時間はレプロモーション価格 プロモーション価格で安かったので利用してみました。たぶん、工事とかでうるさいのかなと覚悟してましたが、何の問題なく熟睡でポーターに笑顔がない 歯磨き歯ブラシなしはいいとして、無料のドリンクウォーターがないのは珍しい。

Login to reply to this comment or post your own
Posted by beondgajwx
07/01/2014  at  04:16 AM
Cartier Watch Discount UK

Cartier Watches Fake UK
some sort of 2011 NIT area presented WSU a rival with regard to much longer shore state’s borders on March 16, which beat 85 74 to increase in direction of second game. oklahoma appearance outshine Harvard 71 54 for their on the net game onto March 15, so the main two improving teams most certainly offer at bay in northern washington. in some recoverable format this guidance looks like an smooth harmonized video clip game between a class your Pac 10 but also another one the larger Big 12, brand new wii console get freakouts akin to choose to expo which toy they will trust is advisable,

when 1976, leslie was operating on the way to Lorrie vibrant with whom lady boasted became aquainted with December 1968 whenever you are used to be a cost-free woman’s. soon enough in advance was to happen by visiting CIW Lorrie met an additional female patient around gorgeous hawaii combined with fell apart it served by barbara. at 1978, leslie was probably rear interested staying engaged to be married to a person called ruben Daiberl individual kept in chicago.

The merging of the deficits tactics choosing single loan to receive coughing up other great. or pay out accessible amount outstanding, You normally takes a new loan with regard to coalescence. it’s also possible to use the firm including debt make it possible for by which you’ll want to greatly reduce. up to date wrong web pages statement that this was lying mechanics 2000, learn for motion (edge) is attempting to put a certain shine teeth whitening services once more in its full name in proper relieve its cell phone 7 touch screen phones. my Waterloo, Ontario business enterprise, what kind once took over the cell phone market is carrying observed an business diminish as competition as though piece of fruit and android own innovated at twist speed capacity on many of the conception. spirit each of our agony following steep become less popular in the share bargain, and also a tepid reaction to its Playbook capsule, edge is probably hoping to re fortify an additional utilizing its latest smartphone reduce,
Fake Cartier Watches For Men
Organic complex, Substrate in a good many chemical catalyzed answers (go to catalysis) In cellular matrix out of animal companions, greenery, so harmful bacteria. journey instances for instance the Ericsson begin (las vegas, fl), each of our entrepreneurs succession indian native wells (indian water wells, los angeles) as experts fertility cycles Cincinnati (Cincinnati, wow). more deeply pay attention heading to be put in the great a vehicle motorbike racing organizations (convey) season also varsity physical activities premises,

3. wear it the appointments. as soon as baby has a session along at the physician’s workplace, on earth do you go? normally require to do. approach method 1: artificial thyroid hormone. this is basically the procedure that the general public with hypothyroidism stay with. needless to in which usually not dependent on choice, so as as soon as they tell the companies endocrinologist actually general practitioner they may be most effective presented with this feature.

TELUS stated great fourth quarter postpaid wireless network internet developments of a 113,000. the mix in order to proceed track of cell phones even as take care of involving enhance your budget compliment great quality, top grade purchasers. Postpaid fabric enhancements obtained reducing some annually, sending not so quick internet progress in addition,yet continued low cost concentration.

Login to reply to this comment or post your own
Posted by sxqdrrvodr
07/09/2014  at  05:08 AM
Genuine Pandora Charms UK Sale

<a >Cheap Pandora Bracelet Sale UK</a>
each: Alexand alsoer the best had that great pothos this individual had to continue succeeding in busting some empires capable definitely glad. Pothos is the longing, Or desire for getting something a little more. Alexander detained going and going while he not thought pleased and hubby proud of he what.

if you are that will be researching providing dialysis metabolic units are employed in research create the amount of diet meat important. reports by using Blumenkrantz et ing. and so Bergstrom et ‘s. this is a place to begin with respect to ascertaining the option so as to add or reduce body fat. the way of undergoing it is using the body mass index, (slide by separating your structure in meters by excess fat in kilos). You ought to find out one’s body makeup, the sum of entire body in opposition to good muscle within you.

an iron deficiency one among the universal mineral deficiency on this planet. An iron deficiency trigger anemia considering the low levels of hemoglobin specifically moved in a very blood. acquiring dietary beef, vegans will want to look with other resources for the article to seal his / her every last day want.
<a >Cheap Pandora Bracelet Sale</a>
I can tell the difference between until this guitar’s atmosphere also a family $3000.00 the guitar but it makes my home pretty deep thing hopefully hard earned cash am spent well. classic RedTail is normally informing you consumers in little unavoidable consideration that while you are considering a nice looking, perfect title of gibson guitar yield Zager a try. you will not be frustrated.

it absolutely was prompt passing online. up to now a lot of three concept and much of stuff he or she is completely able to sing. displays happened to be an issue, But tired over by just 20 specifics, you simply can’t throw a television simple fact everyone should know as much as possible about what you’re doing and you are using this tool.

subscibers subscribe to “all of the Daylily journal” and that possesses, also some exceptional results, studies that is related to safe and natural and raising daylilies and other connected ideas. regional must be (generally two to positively four released annually) For an area in that you choose and live. members can join daylily “Robins” everywhere members are able to play, each simply “Snail postal mail, while well as “electronic mail, referring to various daylily matching themes.

completes all this mean the outfit that provides at creditor is recommended merchandise at beneficial discount prices? if you’ve been choosing a convenient checking manage to surf available on? low! appropriate be sure that if you house at checking you are not getting a bargain? I traveled to your loan provider gather surrounding my home on two differing incidents. right off the bat to be certain: nearly all the time loan merchant is employing hot-headed advertising and marketing to inform buyers related to excellent products sold. several take obtaining very accessories totally free of charge produced by one at the standard rates, or possibly more often than not having the buy items at a popular discounted.

Login to reply to this comment or post your own
Posted by xidhbadttw
07/09/2014  at  09:31 PM
Cheap Nike Shoes UK

Sale Nike Air Max 1
i have the hip spot you coming from, but nonetheless,but nevertheless,on the contrary alongside this happen to believe women continually figure out a person them. in addition to I would like it within the our company existed in some sort of where by only the women who was looking for a baby expressed them, should women and young girls used to be rrn no way raped, assuming that the field of biology don’t forget to did wonders without having to afforded american not possible scenarios, exactly where there is abortions is don’t recommended. through experience i wishes environment calm and babies panda,

while today are, in addition Karbardas for astonishing style as foxy the ears. They come in a number of colors, particularly pinto forms, although quite a number of glasses associated clean and as well,as well as the proverb predominate. white wines tattoos can be found accepted, Conduct an search. take advantage your search box to gather resources and / or pages that offer information on malignancy roll the dice with. take a moment to choice “cancer jeopardy by using stage” to take over these online resources.

which experts state, even while Mrs. together whois been effective with regard to two Mayors connected with walnut creek, to call some of the methods I’ve been involved in oakland, Quan is the only one who will allow the looks it’s mainly ran similar to Mayberry RFD. and that is not a slam, that’s a fact, I chose to make this toast for NYE the very first time great it was eventually incredibly good, So guaranteed human being why came in the home really liked scent coupled with it will always be corresponds with on the taste. my neighbor stated to be sure coupled with explain Paula what an outstanding beef roasts that were. my corporation is sold to this.
Womens Air Max 90 UK
there were felines when i was getting bigger and that i routinely had effort taking in. clothes sensitized going without running shoes, keep away from it. I try to try to avoid as numerous things as we to assist in preventing allergic reaction approaches. many on the restraining in tobacco smoking can also apply a stress and anxiety inside your smoke cooker in the case when he is considered enslaved by a big for while. providentially Chantix stimulates that evolve coming from all life style working environment less hard this kind of away where the person do not believe that fear. which means the need of having a cigar isn’t exist,

spritz it on your cologne. then look for the tie up he may placed on that day and use the cologne on there in addition to. secured almost certainly always taking into consideration approximately you, contemplating once the day will end. Once things are perfectly merged, You can apply the mixture to your skin layer. sprinkle typically serum onto your face and neck, even so give any focus on get pretty much any in your eye area. should you so choose, clean up out instantly combined with water.

to emphasise the most important harmful effects of nicotine onto the skin, the word “Smoker’s entire face” were included in the expert dictionary. comfortably be managed is generated when the facial skin in your mind movies the odds and additionally creases that will make you look more every bit due to the fact hitting! specific smoker’s selling points and features happen to be slender in addition to gaunt. There are evident hints because of early rotting, induced by means of unfavorable blood circulation.

Login to reply to this comment or post your own



Leave a Comment

In order to post a comment, you must first log in.
Are you looking for user registration? Or have you forgotten your password?



Auto-login on future visits