Thursday, October 18, 2012 | return to: views, editorial


Free speech belongs on campus

Follow j. on   and 

It’s not hyperbole to say that the college campus is America’s front line in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Nowhere else is the rhetoric as heated, mendacious and potentially dangerous.

Few campuses have seen as much anti-Israel vitriol as those in the University of California system. The problem has persisted for so long, we felt the time had come to ask U.C.’s Jewish students their opinions about the campus climate.

Our reports from U.C. campuses in Berkeley, Davis and Santa Cruz paint a picture of relative calm punctuated by flare-ups of anti-Israel and anti-Semitic activity.

For the most part, Jewish students thrive in these intellectually stimulating institutions. They are free to opt in on campus Jewish life, with its Jewish Studies programs, clubs, Greek houses, Hillels and Chabad centers. They are just as free to opt out, if they choose.

At the same time, student-sponsored BDS (boycott, divestment and sanctions) efforts against Israel and “Israel Apartheid Week” events have made many Jewish students feel unwelcome, even afraid. Hecklers and protesters have done their best to make campuses unfriendly territory for visiting Israeli speakers.

Some students have accused the university of tolerating a hostile, at times anti-Semitic environment. These charges have morphed into lawsuits and federal investigations.

No one can deny that carving a swastika into a dormitory bathroom door is an anti-Jewish act. Certainly direct threats and physical assaults constitute hate crimes and must never be tolerated.

However, as so many thoughtful students profiled in our stories this week point out, free speech is as close to a sacred right as we have in this country. Subsumed under the First Amendment is the right to say hurtful, hateful and even untrue things.

None of the students interviewed, even the most ardently pro-Israel, wanted any infringement of free speech enforced on their campuses.

It’s only natural that parents try to protect their children, and that we, the collective Jewish community, would likewise strive to spare Jewish students the discomfort of hateful speech.

Let us remember, once they reach college age, they are not children anymore. We do Jewish students a disservice if we patronize them, infantilize them and try to spare them from every insult.

Jewish students are tough enough to take the slings and arrows, and smart enough to fight back with their own free speech. Our job is to support them when they ask for it.


Posted by Michael Harris
10/19/2012  at  06:36 PM
Why FUND hate speech?

It is, admittedly, very difficult to determine the boundaries between free speech and hate speech in such a way that hate speech can be legislatively prohibited.  However, granting the rights of anti-Israel individuals and groups to free speech on (and off) campus doesn’t mean that hate speech has to be supported by the university—especially with public funds.  So if members of SJP want to spread lies about “apartheid” and support the Hamas agenda, they can. But the university can write regulations that would prevent them from receiving funding to bring in their speakers—just as a white supremacist group on campus shouldn’t get funding to bring in David Duke.

Login to reply to this comment or post your own

Leave a Comment

In order to post a comment, you must first log in.
Are you looking for user registration? Or have you forgotten your password?

Auto-login on future visits