Thursday, September 27, 2012 | return to: views, editorial


Foreign heads of state have no place in U.S. elections

Follow j. on   and 

Is Bibi stumping for Mitt?

Some in the punditocracy have questioned whether Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has inserted himself into American electoral politics.

He denies it, but circumstantial evidence exists for the charge.

Recently, Netanyahu has pressed the Obama administration to draw a “red line” in front of Iran’s nuclear ambitions. He would like to see the United States declare its willingness — perhaps even eagerness — to attack Iran by a certain date if that country does not stand down.

This put President Barack Obama on the defensive. When he refused to draw a red line, it triggered criticism from his Republican opponent, Mitt Romney. Score one for Team Romney, with an assist from Netanyahu.

In a political ad now airing in Florida and produced by a pro-Romney super PAC, Netanyahu is featured front and center decrying global inaction on the Iranian issue. “The world tells Israel, wait there’s still time,” Netanyahu says in the ad. “And I say, wait for what?”

And by “world,” he surely means the U.S. president.

This came on the heels of a diplomatic flap involving Obama supposedly refusing to meet with Netanyahu during the latter’s visit to New York this week for the U.N. General Assembly. Both sides claimed no visit had been requested and none denied. Yet a sense of ongoing frostiness between the two leaders lingered.

That, along with the drumbeat of alarm over a perceived deterioration of U.S.-Israeli relations, as asserted by Republicans and some Jewish leaders, added to the partisan outcry.

Jews are not single-issue voters. Yes, Israel matters deeply, but Jews cast their votes based on a variety of concerns, Middle East politics being only one of them.

Netanyahu stated clearly to CNN that some might attempt to “draw me into the American election, and I’m not going to do that.”

These were the right words, but they won’t stop campaigns from seeking to score political points using Netanyahu as their poster child. No foreign leader, even the head of a friendly nation like Israel, should come down on one side or the other of a U.S. election.

The truth is the United States has been Israel’s greatest ally with Obama in the White House, and will remain so no matter who wins in November. Netanyahu should not, must not, pick sides in this election. We’ll decide it for ourselves.


Posted by Frank
09/29/2012  at  08:10 PM
A terrible anti-Israel (and therefore anti-Jewish) editorial.

American Jews may not be “single-issue” voters, but there is a “single-issue” which trumps all others, and makes them all irrelevant:  the survival of the Jewish State of Israel, and therefore the safety and future of the Jewish people.

Leftist American Jews who seek to propagandize against that single, overriding, crucial issue by criticizing the Prime Minister of Israel doing everything that he can to save the Jewish State and its millions of Jewish inhabitants from a second Holocaust by Iranian nuclear annihilation, are placing their narrow personal political agenda before the lives and safety of the Jewish people.

For American Jews this should be the pre-eminent defining issue in the “election”.

Of course we will “decide for ourselves”.  And in so doing we will decide for the Jewish people now and for future generations.

Any Jewish publication that would in its editorial argue against Israel’s Prime Minister speaking to the world about the inaction on the impending nuclear attack on Israel by Iran, has made its partisanship primary to its alleged concern for Israel.

It is false, patently false, to claim that,” the United States has been Israel’s greatest ally with Obama in the White House”.  He is the most anti-Israel president in history.

If Obama is re-elected, American Jews will be of no further use to him, and he will be finally free to entirely abandon any American political, military or diplomatic support of Israel, and allow Iran its nukes.

Jewish American Democrats (who are not in denial and support Israel) are left with a stark choice: 

Your political party or your people.

Login to reply to this comment or post your own

Leave a Comment

In order to post a comment, you must first log in.
Are you looking for user registration? Or have you forgotten your password?

Auto-login on future visits