Thursday, June 28, 2012 | return to: news & features, international


With Muslim Brotherhood’s ascendancy, Mubarak’s legacy is upended

by ron kampeas, jta

Follow j. on   and 

Muslim Brotherhood candidate Mohamed Morsi is the declared winner of Egypt’s presidential race and his predecessor, Hosni Mubarak, reportedly is near death in a coma — just like the legacy he tried to craft for himself and his country.

Mubarak, 84, once the entrenched leader of his land, was supposed to be leaving behind an Egypt preeminent in the region and at peace with its neighbors. The final moments of his public career, however, are now another dramatic episode of the so-called Arab Spring, which began in late 2010 when a Tunisian fruit vendor set himself on fire to protest his country’s government.

Since then, popular uprisings have threatened or toppled Arab leaders once firmly in power not only in Egypt and Tunisia, but also in Bahrain, Libya, Syria and Yemen.

Early last year Mubarak’s powerful military — whose air force he once commanded — sided with throngs of protesters across the nation, but particularly in Cairo’s Tahrir Square. Mubarak subsequently was sentenced to prison for the deaths of hundreds of those protesters.

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu (left) with Egyptian President Hosni Mubarak in Egypt less than three weeks before Mubarak’s downfall, January 2011.   photo/jta/gpo-flash90/moshe milner
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu (left) with Egyptian President Hosni Mubarak in Egypt less than three weeks before Mubarak’s downfall, January 2011. photo/jta/gpo-flash90/moshe milner
Despite new demonstrations in recent weeks — this time against the military — the grip of the armed forces on the country does not seem threatened for now. The Egyptian military has rewritten the country’s constitution and persuaded judges to strip much of the power of the presidency. The judges have dissolved the country’s parliament, which had a Muslim Brotherhood majority following last year’s elections.

During Mubarak’s reign from 1981 until early last year, the Muslim Brotherhood was a target of the security apparatus. But on June 24, Egypt’s electoral commission said Morsi would be sworn in as the president, having bested Ahmed Shafiq, Mubarak’s last prime minister and reportedly the favored candidate of the military.

Israel’s government reacted cautiously.

“Israel appreciates the democratic process in Egypt and respects the results of the presidential elections,” according to a statement from the prime minister’s office. It added, “Israel looks forward to continuing cooperation with the Egyptian government on the basis of the peace treaty between the two countries, which is a joint interest of both peoples and contributes to regional stability.”

Israeli and American leaders are clearly nervous; the Muslim Brotherhood’s leaders have said they would honor but re-examine the landmark 1979 Israeli-Egyptian peace treaty.

Gabi Ashkenazi, the former chief of staff of the Israeli military, spoke of Mubarak’s importance not just in upholding the peace treaty with Israel, but also in encouraging other Arabs to do the same.

“When Arafat was slow to sign the Oslo Accords, Mubarak was the one who forced him to the table to sign — even using undiplomatic language,” Ashkenazi recalled, referring to Oslo II, signed in September 1995 in Egypt.

Mubarak, in a televised ceremony, literally nudged then–Palestinian Authority President Yasser Arafat to the table as a bemused Yitzhak Rabin, then the Israeli prime minister, looked on. Israelis present insisted that they heard Mubarak whisper to Arafat, “Sign, you dog.”

“Try to think of an Egyptian president today doing that,” Ashkenazi said.

“Whatever happens, we will be facing a more radical regime,” said Kadima Party leader Shaul Mofaz in Washington, D.C., where he addressed the Washington Institute for Near East Policy ahead of a series of meetings with top U.S. officials. Israel’s new deputy prime minister called the need to preserve his country’s peace with Egypt the “highest Israeli goal.”

“Mubarak’s legacy is that he created a state system that collapsed underneath him,” said Joel Rubin, a former Senate staffer and State Department Egypt desk officer who directs government policy at the Ploughshares Fund. “He certainly maintained peace with Israel — a cold peace, but he kept the border relatively calm and fought against extremist groups in the country. But he left a crushing legacy on the economy and political system. Stability under strongmen is never really stable.”

Mubarak spurred privatization reforms in the 1990s that helped grow Egypt’s economy, but they did not trickle down because he also tolerated — if not encouraged — the kleptocracy of the Egyptian elites, said David Schenker, an Egypt expert at the Washington Institute and a former Pentagon Middle East official.

Ultimately, the thieving weakened Egypt’s economy and undercut its regional influence. Whereas in the 1990s Mubarak could strong-arm Arafat into peace, in the 2000s he was barely able to get the Palestinian polity, split between Hamas Islamists and Palestinian Authority moderates, to heed his pleas for a unified front.

“There is no longer respect or fear of Egypt,” Schenker said. “Mubarak presided over this.”


Be the first to comment!

Leave a Comment

In order to post a comment, you must first log in.
Are you looking for user registration? Or have you forgotten your password?

Auto-login on future visits