President’s ‘Polish death camp’ faux-pas is a common mistakeby michael berenbaum
|Follow j. on||and|
President Barack Obama made a simple and very basic mistake when he spoke of Polish death camps during the presentation of a posthumous Medal of Freedom to Jan Karski, a Polish resistance fighter who was among the first to report German atrocities in his country.
During the May 29 ceremony, the president discussed how the Polish un-derground “smuggled [Karski] into the Warsaw Ghetto and a Polish death camp to see for himself.”
The next day, after objections from the Polish government, a spokesman for the U.S. National Security Council said the president “misspoke” and meant “Nazi death camps in Poland.”
There were death camps and they were situated in Poland — deliberately so — but there were no Polish death camps. The most accurate way to refer to these camps is “Nazi death camps in German-occupied Poland.”
Let me tell you why: Poland was occupied by Germany. Occupation was an act of state, not of the Nazi Party. So there was no Nazi occupation, no Nazi army, no Nazi laws. There was German occupation, a German army — the Wehrmacht — and German laws. These were instruments of the state.
These mistakes are all too common even in articles written by scholars and historians. For example, the Encyclopedia of the Holocaust commonly refers to Nazi occupation. Its editor is a distinguished scholar.
Acts undertaken by the Nazi Party to realize its ideology can be properly referred to as Nazi. Hence the death camps were Nazi in origin, conception and operation, but they were situated in German-occupied Poland, an area known as the General Gouvernment (except for Auschwitz, which was situated in Upper Silesia, and Chelmno, located in the Warthegau, now Poznan).
Another caution: Between September 1939 and June 1941, western Poland was occupied by Germany and eastern Poland by the Soviet Union. So Soviet — not Russian — occupation was the rule in eastern Poland for 22 months. Thereafter, Germany occupied these lands until the Soviet Union re-entered these territories in its march to victory in 1944 and 1945.
In the areas incorporated into the Reich, all existing Polish institutions were dissolved and new administrative units were established. In the occupied but nonincorporated territories, not all Polish institutions were dissolved.
One other common mistake: Many write of the Jews who “perished” in the Holocaust. Jews did not perish in the Holocaust; they were murdered, annihilated.
Extermination is a Nazi term, something that is done to vermin and rats, not to people. We should not use Nazi terms, except when we specify that they are Nazi terms.
The Poles are properly sensitive to the common mistake of speaking of Polish death camps. They have labored hard in the post-Communist era to correct this mistake and to change common usage. Their efforts deserve our support. Simply put, they are truthful.
The president’s speechwriters ill-served him and ill-served the late Jan Karski, the man so deserving of the Presidential Medal of Freedom. They should have known better or verified these matters. The president’s mistake is entirely forgivable. I can cite many distinguished scholars who have made the very same mistake.
His correction is equally proper. It might go a long way toward ensuring that this mistake is not repeated. n
Michael Berenbaum is director of the Sigi Ziering Institute: Exploring the Ethical and Religious Implications of the Holocaust at the American Jewish University. This piece first appeared on jta.org.
Be the first to comment!