resources
Thursday, December 8, 2011 | return to: news & features, local


Share
 

Israel advocate John Rothmann loses slot in KGO firings

by andy altman-ohr, j. staff

Follow j. on   and 

John Rothmann often used his KGO radio talk shows in a way many Bay Area Jews could appreciate.

He provided a pro-Israel take on Middle East news and was able to give a forum to guests — be they authors or diplomats or Middle East experts — who were Jewish or Israeli.

That all came to an end last week when Cumulus Media, the new owners of KGO 810 AM, dismissed seven of the station’s veteran talk show hosts, including Rothmann. Cumulus changed the format to focus less on talk and more on news.

“John’s made-for-radio voice, extraordinary memory and extemporaneous speaking genius, combined with his love of San Francisco, American politics and history made him a great talk show host,” said Rabbi Doug Kahn, executive director of the S.F.-based Jewish Community Relations Council and a longtime Rothmann friend.

John Rothmann
John Rothmann
“His love of the Jewish community and Israel were the icing on the cake,” Kahn added, “a reassuring and consistently friendly voice on the air who was unafraid to take on any challengers.”

Rothmann’s shows included a wide range of topics and guests, but there always seemed to be a place for someone like Israeli firefighter Shachar Tsairy (one of Rothmann’s final guests last week) or Israeli Ambassador to the U.S. Michael Oren (a recent guest).

 “There’s no question that I took full advantage of my contacts in terms of the Jewish community and the Middle East to represent a broad spectrum of Israeli opinion to the community,” Rothmann said this week. “I covered left, right and center.”

Rothmann took the firing in stride, as format changes in the radio business are to be expected. He was at KGO for what he deemed “15 wonderful years,” adding that he “enjoyed every minute of it.” For many years, he did the overnight shift on weekends, then in 2009 was promoted to the 10 p.m.–to–1 a.m. slot on weekdays.

A fourth-generation San Franciscan with myriad connections to the Jewish community, Rothmann was buoyed by the outpouring of support that he — and the other fired hosts — received from emotionally jolted Bay Area listeners who built what felt like personal relationships with KGO’s on-air hosts.

Rothmann said that in the first four days after the news broke, he received more than 1,500 emails and more than 100 phone calls from well-wishers. Moreover, thousands of user comments, many from irate listeners, flooded newspaper websites and blogs. At a high school basketball game, a priest came up to him and said, “John, this is unbelievable.” S.F.-based Israeli Consul General Akiva Tor called to express his feelings.

“The support has been stunning,” Rothmann said. “In a way, I did feel like I was able to attend my own funeral, and the eulogies have been wonderful.”

Tor told j.: “John has been a rigorous and erudite broadcaster, determined to report Israel and the Middle East as it is, not as partisans imagine it.”

Rothmann, 62, said he is now in search mode for a new radio job. He lives in San Francisco with his wife, Ellen, and his son Joel, who will be having his bar mitzvah in Israel next summer. His other son, Samuel, is a freshman at U.C. Davis. They are members of Congregation Emanu-El.

Rothmann’s connections to the Jewish community include the Zionist Organization of America (former regional president), Jewish National Fund (former regional president, current regional board chairman), JCRC (member since 1974) and Bay Area Council for Soviet Jewry (former president). He has emceed dozens of community events over the years, including Israel in the Gardens many times.

“My voice will still be out there,” Rothmann said.

The firing storm at KGO, which management blamed on subpar ratings, swept away two other Jews, on-air lawyer Len Tillem and news talk host Gil Gross. Longtime morning host Ronn Owens (born Ronald Lowenstein) retained his job. The other fired hosts were Gene Burns, Ray Taliaferro, Joanie Greggains and Bill Wattenburg.

All of them had their own unique voice, but none went to bat for the Jewish community like Rothmann did.

“I think my advocacy for Israel [on the air] was not only important as an educational tool, but an important statement for me as a figure in the media who was not hesitant in expressing the fact that Israel must have friends,” he said. “In all the years I’ve been on the radio, I’ve never hung my head or declined to stand up for things I believe in.”


Comments

Posted by dyannne
12/08/2011  at  01:56 PM
Missing John!

John’s comment, “In a way, I did feel like I was able to attend my own funeral, and the eulogies have been wonderful…” is music to my ears. And I can hear him (in my head) saying that. Sounds just like him! I rarely missed a night with John Rothmann. Didn’t always agree with him, sometimes found him too conservative for my taste, but always found him intelligent, provocative, interesting and educational. His listeners to a one are incensed at the way this company treated him. No   announcement, no farewell, re-runs of his show without a heads up, adding insult to injury with a replacement show of such tastelessness. I hope he will be broadcasting somewhere else soon! If you’re reading this, John, know that there is no place we would rawther be than right there with you! grin

Login to reply to this comment or post your own
Posted by mblackbird3
12/08/2011  at  03:04 PM
SHAME ON KGO!!!

How could they let go such a treasure and a gift to the airwaves as John Rothman?  We were so fortunate to live in an area where we could tune in to interesting & varied viewpoints and local hosts.  John was my all time favorite…a voice of reason and entertainment..Truly a gifted source of information. I was looking forward to hearing his comments during the upcoming presidential election period.
John knows about history, law, comedy, music. He was always enjoyable to listen to .
John will go on to do fine, I am sure.  However, the listeners will be poorer for this loss.  I am not Jewish but he spoke to all religions and beliefs with respect and intelligence.  Marvelous collections and memory.  Bah! Humbug, KGO!!
We miss you John!!

Login to reply to this comment or post your own
Posted by ssholin
12/08/2011  at  07:43 PM
What is KGO thinking?

We can only hope that KGO will suffer in the ratings, try to bring back these brilliant hosts and find they have moved on to better things. Gil, Len, Gene, Joanie, the best. So sad.

Login to reply to this comment or post your own
Posted by Lita Perna
12/08/2011  at  10:04 PM
Gornisht mit Gornisht

John Rothmann is a treasure.
You get what you pay for.
Kgo has replaced John Rothmann with Drec*k.

When I’d hear an important news story I always looked forward to listening to John’s view of it.
He was able to explain what it meant, or could mean, and asked the important questions.

I always learned something.

Sometimes listening to John was like sitting in a graduate school class.

He often astonished me, not only with his brilliance and depth of knowledge but by his courage and his ability to keep cool in the face of ignorance, rage and anti-Semitism.

Someone here said they were so fortunate to live in an area where they could tune in to interesting & varied viewpoints and local hosts.
I listened from Chicago and considered myself fortunate to live in a world where I could tune in to John Rothmann.

No more.

I miss him terribly and second the statement that was made above, “There’s no place I’d rather be than here with you.”

Zay gezunt

Lita Perna
Chicago, Illinois

Login to reply to this comment or post your own
Posted by HCochet
12/08/2011  at  11:04 PM
"shame on KGO" I second it

I sure miss all the fired hosts on KGO. I agree with the person who said “you get what you pay for”. To quote author/writer Joel Drucker “If you pay peanuts, you get monkeys” and that’s what KGO has now. John Rothman could take a subject that I consider boring, politics and make it very interesting. I read and very much enjoyed three books because of John. “Inside the White House Helicopter”, which led to “The Memoirs of Richard Nixon”, and “I gave them a sword” by David Frost. I also watched the Frost/Nixon movie because of John Rothman (who worked for Nixon). John, if you read this, I want you to know how much I enjoyed your show and will miss it. Also, the music you played was on topic and fantastic.

Login to reply to this comment or post your own
Posted by Dan Calic
12/09/2011  at  01:24 AM
Taking away the only newstalk

Taking away the only newstalk station in order to directly compete against another all news station seems like bad business.

The fact that the light of a lone candle who shined in a stadium full of darkness, as John Rothmann has done for so many years has now been snuffed out leaves a huge void in desperately needed voices for Israel. His crisp comments and razor sharp instant recall brought balance and clarity to flashpoint issues. His termination is not only a great loss for Bay Area listeners, it is a wound to all of us who stand for and with Israel. Kol Hakavod John!
~ Dan Calic

Login to reply to this comment or post your own
Posted by Rayvyn
12/09/2011  at  08:55 PM
Big Fan Of Rothmann

I’m a fan of Rothmann. Have been for years, since he was doing late night weekend shows. I was glad when they moved him to weekdays. He does topics on movies, science fiction and history. I hope he finds a station or other outlet. I hear that Rothmann, Taliaferro, and Burns might wind up on the same station somewhere. But that’s a rumor. Maybe they could broadcast over the Internet. Start their own Internet station. We need to keep local talk shows.

I live in Oakland and when something major happened with crime or other issues. Rothmann talked about it and let the callers talk about it too. We need that kind of thing again!

Login to reply to this comment or post your own
Posted by lynkimes
12/09/2011  at  09:44 PM
Finally learned who shot JR

After waiting for years to listen to my talk show hero at a descent time of day, I was lucky enough to have a couple of years to get inside his head every night.  On finding out that he was not on as usual, I sent two emails to the station (with no response as to what had happened to him), I finally googled enough to find out the news. 

I rarely agreed with him politically or religiously, but immensely enjoyed his ability to treat all callers fairly….even Michael from Cotati, probably the most articulate regular caller. 

John has an amazing memory and based on his instant responses, he has to have read every one of his 15,000 political books.  I have no doubt that someone will recognize his talent and offer him a slot in the media with coverage large enough to share his talent with as many human beings as possible. 

NOTE TO JR: THERE IS NO DOUBT IN MY MIND THAT THIS IS A BLESSING IN DISGUISE.  YOU WILL LIKELY BE OFFERED OPPORTUNITIES YOU NEVER DREAMED POSSIBLE.

Login to reply to this comment or post your own
Posted by Dan Calic
12/09/2011  at  10:57 PM
Occupy KGO Rally Dec. 15

Since the mass execution at KGO the remaining staff is walking around in shock and sadness, longtime advertisers have pulled their ads, Ronn Owens has apparently survived for the time being, but seems to have alienated himself somewhat with his post execution comments. The Bay Area listening audience remains in disbelief over this.

For those who wish to show the owners of KGO how much they oppose what’s happened an “Occupy KGO” rally is scheduled for Dec. 15th at 11:30 outside their studio- 900 Front St. Please consider sending a strong message to the owners by attending.

To keep up on this and other inside info here’s a site-
http://richliebermanreport.blogspot.com/
~ Dan Calic

Login to reply to this comment or post your own
Posted by Janice
12/13/2011  at  09:12 PM
Stupid KGO

I didn’t always agree with John Rothmann but I will miss him. Knowing what I do about the terrible treatment that the Israelis have meted out to the Palestinians I found it difficult to listen to his continuous praise of Israel. Nevertheless I found his voice on other issues to be in sync with mine.
KGO now has a dumbed-down formatt not worth listening to.
My radio dial is now turned to KQED or to Green960 which, unfortunately is due to become another dumbed down station featuring the likes of Glenn Beck.
The Bay Area deserves better..

Login to reply to this comment or post your own
Posted by ripkens8
12/13/2011  at  11:09 PM
WE MISS THE VOICE IN THE NIGHT

Dear John: We are so sad that we can’t hear you on KGO. My husband & I would lay in bed at night listening to your soothing voice. The Presidential history was so facinating. If we want to hear constant news, KCBS is there, BUT, we want to hear people calling in. After Ronn, we switch off. We think that you, Gene & Gil should all form your own talk radio station? How about it? We’ll keep looking for you somewhere in the future,
Have a Happy Hannukah & a great new year.
Sincerely, Brian & Joyce
Granville - Pittsburg, CA

Login to reply to this comment or post your own
Posted by Stahhhhnnn Paaaakkkiiii
12/26/2011  at  10:11 AM
I found John a total gasbag

I am of Pakistani origin and have never appreciated the defamatory manner in which Mr. Rothman pronounced my country. I fond him a hypocritical blow hard who despite his seemingly knowledge of the region never spent any time in the region on the ground so to speak. I thank KGO for firing this blow hard and only fault them for having them associated with their station for so long. There are several deli’s in my area looking for people of Mr. Rothman’s abilities. Yes I’ll take a turkey on rye Mr. Rothman and hold the mayo. From Paaaakkkkkiiiistaaahhhn

Login to reply to this comment or post your own
Posted by solarblast
01/02/2012  at  07:15 AM
Pres .Andrew Johnson

Saw a wonderful old movie on TCM a week ago, Tennessee Johnson. The story of Andrew Johnson. I think you recommended a recent book on his life in the last year or two. What was the name of the book?

Login to reply to this comment or post your own
Posted by Sylvia94404
01/05/2012  at  06:14 PM
So many people miss you

Hello John,

I’m listening to you on 910 right now but can only get it on the Internet. I hope you get your own show soon and are on a station I can get on my radio.

I tried to email you but it came back because it was the KGO address. Cumulus should be ashamed and very sorry for firing the very best hosts. They will be sorry as they’re ratings have fallen already. I don’t listen to KGO any longer as thousands have done the same. It’s so frustrating not to be able to reach you. Please let us know where you will be permanently.

You are missed terribly and at this crucial time in politics.

Sincerely,

Sylvia

Login to reply to this comment or post your own
Posted by Hat
02/22/2012  at  09:40 AM
I miss John on KGO

If John Rothmann gets another radio show, please let me know.  I miss him so much.  The Cumulus new hires are disasters!  I no longer listen to KGO.  Paula

Login to reply to this comment or post your own
Posted by annkndy
02/29/2012  at  01:37 PM
Please, please let us know

Please, please let us know where John R. can be heard now.

Login to reply to this comment or post your own



Leave a Comment

In order to post a comment, you must first log in.
Are you looking for user registration? Or have you forgotten your password?



Auto-login on future visits