Thursday, August 19, 2010 | return to: views, editorial


Hillels to be commended for proactive stance

Follow j. on   and 

Earlier this year, it seemed not a week went by without this newspaper reporting on anti-Israel activity in the Bay Area, especially on college campuses.

U.C. Berkeley emerged as the local epicenter of the boycott, divestment and sanctions movement (BDS), with Cal’s student senate barely defeating an Israel divestment bill last semester.

Some in the Jewish community fretted at the time that Jewish students and Jewish campus organizations fell short in mounting countercampaigns. They worried the pro-Israel message faded amid the din of anti-Israel hysteria.

This week we learned some encouraging news. With the new school year, Hillels across the country intend to be more proactive.

Hillel has long been a haven for Jewish college students seeking a taste of home. With the surge in anti-Israel activity on campus — from BDS petitions to shouting down visiting Israeli speakers –– Hillel had to adopt another role: help Jewish students deflect efforts to delegitimize Israel.

This summer, students and Hillel administrators from across the country attended workshops, one of which taught students and staffers  to effectively prepare for and respond to anti-Israel activism.

In one simulation, the student government of a fictional university put forth a bill to have the institution divest from Israel. Participants devised methods for defeating the bill. Launching divestment measures has become a key component in the national strategy of campus anti-Israel activists.

Fortunately, thus far divestment bills have been defeated in all but one small college in the Northwest. But as Hillel leaders noted in our story on page 2, the activists no doubt will be back this coming school year, and most likely with a vengeance.

The anti-Israel camp, especially on campus, has grown increasingly well organized. Its supporters have mastered the art of messaging and, in some cases, spreading disinformation.

In the past, pro-Israel students and mainstream Jewish groups on campus were caught flatfooted time and again. Eager to appear accommodating or to avoid stridency, they struggled to persuade fellow students that there are two sides to this story.

The tide may be turning. With Hillel making this concerted effort, we may soon see a more balanced debate and a more vigorous rejection of shrill anti-Israel voices.

With the end of summer, students are returning to campus. Like so many in the Jewish community, we hope for a respectful dialogue. But if not, we trust the pro-Israel side is ready.


Posted by Dan Spitzer
08/20/2010  at  02:56 PM
Hillel Has been the Petri Dish of the BDS Movement at UC Berkeley

When I first read this editorial (and the piece with the same bent) in current J, I thought it was a satire. Surely, J’s editor and reporters were aware of what has been widespread knowledge in the Jewish community: that as Mr. Kessler noted above, Hillel has been the petri dish for the BDS movement on the UC Berkeley campus.

Indeed, Hillel has indeed played host to Students for Justice in Palestine and their Jewish cronies, Kesher Enoshi (which also supports BDS). These two anti-Israel groups have participated in numerous student meetings at Hillel and converted a number of vulnerable, impressionable students to the pro-Palestinian cause.

Moreover, several of these convertees and Kesher members subsequently played a role in convincing a majority on UCB’s student government to pass a bill advocating divestment from Israel. Fortunately, the student government’s fair-minded president vetoed the bill.

All of the above transpired under the watch of Rabbi Kelman, who did little to curtail it until finally participating himself in opposition the divestment bill. One might say, too little and too late. Fortunately, by one shaky vote the veto was upheld.

It will be instructive to see what the largely to date inert rabbi overseeing Hillel will permit at Hillel in the upcoming semester. If Rabbi Kelman continues to sit on his hands and permits pro-Palestinian students to use Hillel as their staging ground, disaster on campus and a growth of support for the pro-Palestinian movement is likely to continue apace.

If you read J and are unaware of the above, it’s not for the lack of trying by those of us who have been attempting to alter this appalling situation. Alas, the editor of this publication has refused to print numerous letters concerning this issue—so much for freedom of the press and the right to express a dissenting perspective in J…

Login to reply to this comment or post your own
Posted by Dan Spitzer
08/20/2010  at  03:20 PM

When I referred to Mr. Kessler’s comments above, I was citing his astute observations about Hillel which may be read on line under J’s featured piece-a travesty of truth-
“Hillels Prepare to
Answer Anti-Israel Campus Forces.”

Login to reply to this comment or post your own

Leave a Comment

In order to post a comment, you must first log in.
Are you looking for user registration? Or have you forgotten your password?

Auto-login on future visits